There has been a lot talk about the changes to the business environment in Silicon Valley post “dot com”. I thought it would be of interest to share with you a compilation made by the law firm of Fenwick and West with respect to how a typical first round funding looks pre and post “dot com bubble".Izhar
TERM
|
THEN |
…AND NOW |
Valuation:
|
$15-$100 million pre-money |
$3-$10 million pre-money |
Investment Amount:
|
$5-$30 million |
$2-$10 million |
Number of Investors:
|
Single VC investor |
At least 2 VC investors |
Closing Cycle:
|
1-2 months |
3-4 months |
Closings:
|
Single tranche investment |
Milestone-based tranches |
Dividends:
|
Non-mandatory, non-cumulative 8% per year |
Mandatory, cumulative, payable in kind 15% per year |
Liquidation Preference:
|
1Xpurchase price, plus participation rights to 3X |
3X purchase price, plus participation rights with no cap |
Redemption: |
None |
At option of holders after 5 years at purchase price accrued dividends
|
Automatic Conversion: |
Upon Qualified IPO of $50 million, no price limit |
Upon Qualified IPO $25 million, and at least 5X purchase price
|
Antidilution Protection: |
Standard broad-based weighted average adjustment |
Full ratchet adjustment for a period; then weighted average
|
Board Composition: |
2 VC’s; 2 Common; 1 Outsider |
Same
|
Protective Provisions: |
Investor approval of: senior securities, sale of company, payment of dividends, liquidation, change of rights |
Investor approval of senior or pari passu securities, sale of company, payment of dividends, change of rights, change of business, incurrence of debt over specified limit, annual budgets and variances, acquisitions of other businesses, grant of exclusive rights in technology, appointment or termination of CEO
|
Pre-emptive Rights: |
Right to maintain pro-rata ownership in later financings |
Right to invest 2X pro-rata ownership in later financing
|
Most Favored Nations Treatment: |
None |
Right to get any more favorable terms granted in later financings
|
Pay to Play Provisions: |
Often used; preferred loses anti-dilution protection if don’t participate in later financing at lower price |
More common now; preferred automatically converts to common if don’t participate in later financing at lower price
|
First Refusal Rights: |
Right to purchase any shares proposed to be sold by employees |
Right to purchase any shares proposed to be sold by any shareholder
|
Co-Sale Rights: |
Right to sell alongside any founder that sells shares |
Right to sell alongside any shareholder that sells shares
|
Drag-Along Rights: |
None |
Right to force all shareholders to sell company upon board and majority shareholder approval
|
Forced Sale: |
None |
Right to force board to sell company after 5 years if no IPO
|
Founder Vesting: |
Standard 4-year vesting with some up-front vesting |
Moving to 5-year vesting
|
Employment Agreements: |
None |
Employment agreements for key founders
|
Representations and Warranties: |
From company only |
Some reps and warranties from founders individually re IP etc
|